Malaysian radio operator fined US$57,000 for video mocking Hindu ritual, escapes licence suspension

Incident and Fine: A Radio Station’s Misstep

In a notable turn of events, Era FM, a prominent Malaysian radio channel, faced a significant consequence for a controversial video posted on their Instagram account. The video, which mocked a Hindu ritual, led to the station being fined RM250,000 (approximately $56,657 USD) by the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC). This decision came after Era FM’s operator, Maestra Broadcast Sdn Bhd, successfully appealed against a license suspension notice.

Appeal and Reprieve: A Second Chance

The MCMC’s decision to impose a fine instead of suspending the license was influenced by several factors. These included the company’s prompt corrective actions, such as removing the offensive video, and formal apologies from those involved. The commission acknowledged the potential broader impact of a suspension, which would have affected other channels, Mix FM and Melody, operating under the same license. This consideration highlighted the balance between accountability and the safeguarding of other unrelated businesses.

The Video and Its Fallout: Public and Political Reactions

The incident began on March 4, when the video featuring radio hosts Nabil Ahmad, Azad Jasmin, and Radin Amir Affendy mimicking the kavadi ritual during Thaipusam sparked outrage. The video’s removal and subsequent apologies did little to quell the backlash, as Malaysian leaders, including Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, called for greater respect for religious practices. This public uproar led to 73 police reports and further investigations, underscoring the sensitivity and gravity of the situation.

Suspension Considerations and Broader Implications

The initial suspension notice on March 7 drew criticism from various political figures, who deemed it harsh and unfair to other staff members. M. Saravanan of the Malaysian Indian Congress and Khairi Zainol Abidin from Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia’s youth wing argued against the suspension, emphasizing the innocence of other employees. The MCMC’s decision to fine instead of suspend reflected a nuanced approach, considering both accountability and the broader implications for unrelated staff and channels.

MCMC’s Role and Commitment to Harmony

The MCMC’s stance was clear: upholding the law while preserving racial and religious harmony. The fine, issued under Section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998, aimed to address the offensive content without escalation. This approach highlighted the importance of responsible media conduct and the need to comply with legal standards, ensuring a harmonious multiracial and multi-religious society.

Conclusion: Reflections on Sensitivity and Legal Adherence

Communications Minister Fahmi Fadzil’s assurance that no further action would be taken against the hosts added a layer of closure, acknowledging their distress. The incident serves as a crucial reminder of the importance of cultural sensitivity and legal adherence in media. It underscores the delicate balance between freedom of expression and respect for diverse traditions, essential in maintaining social cohesion in a multicultural society like Malaysia.