All-Time Favorite Romcoms Ranked – Newsweek

1. Introduction: The Poll and Its Findings

Valentine’s Day is often a time when couples seek to reconnect and create memories, and what better way to do that than through a heartfelt movie night? To uncover the most cherished romantic comedies for this special day, Paired, a relationship app focused on enhancing connections through interactive tools, conducted a poll with 1,700 respondents. The results, featured in Newsweek, revealed some classic favorites and a few surprises. The poll found that movies like The Notebook, 10 Things I Hate About You, and When Harry Met Sally are top choices, resonating deeply with their audience. Interestingly, 635 respondents opted out of watching romantic movies altogether, highlighting diverse preferences. Aly Bullock, a licensed therapist and Paired’s head of relationships, shared insights into why these films capture our hearts, blending escapism with relatable humor.

2. The Appeal of Timeless Rom-Coms

Romantic comedies offer a unique blend of fantasy and real-life humor, making them a staple for Valentine’s Day. They provide an escape from daily routines, especially for those juggling parenting and work. Movies like The Notebook and 10 Things I Hate About You remind viewers of passionate, all-consuming love, which many find irresistible. On the other hand, films such as Love Actually and When Harry Met Sally strike a balance with humor and emotional depth, resonating with those navigating love’s challenges. These movies are more than just entertainment; they mirror the ups and downs of real relationships, offering both comfort and inspiration.

3. The Enduring Allure and Hidden Complexity of The Notebook

No discussion of romantic movies would be complete without The Notebook, which topped the poll with 350 votes. Its tale of enduring love is undeniably captivating, especially for millennial women who grew up with the film. Bullock, who once listed it as her favorite, acknowledges its romanticized portrayal of love, even as it sometimes borders on toxicity. Yet, the charm of Ryan Gosling’s character is undeniable, making the movie a Valentine’s Day staple. While modern viewers might critique its portrayal of relationships, the emotional impact remains, showing love’s power to transcend time and adversity.

4. Beyond the Mainstream: Diverse Tastes in Romantic Comedies

The poll also revealed a notable diversity in preferences, with 239 respondents choosing "other" as their favorite. This suggests that modern audiences are looking beyond traditional "chick-flicks" for stories that reflect a broader spectrum of love experiences. Whether it’s through unconventional narratives or diverse characters, people are seeking stories that resonate with their unique lives. Bullock notes that this diversity is crucial, as it reflects the varied ways love is experienced today.

5. Refreshing Your Watchlist: Modern and Classic Alternatives

For those looking to try something new, Bullock recommends We Live in Time and The Big Sick, both offering fresh perspectives on love and loss. We Live in Time provides a raw exploration of love, while The Big Sick tells a true story of overcoming adversity. Classic films like The Princess Bride also stand out with their wit and charm, appealing beyond typical rom-com fans. These suggestions encourage viewing diverse love stories, enriching the cinematic experience beyond familiar choices.

6. The Enduring Magic of Romantic Comedies

Romantic comedies continue to captivate audiences with their blend of humor, emotion, and fantasy. They serve as a reminder of love’s potential, offering comfort and joy amidst life’s challenges. While real-life obstacles evolve, these films adapt, providing new stories that resonate with changing times. Whether through escapism or relatable narratives, romantic comedies remain a beloved part of Valentine’s Day traditions, inspiring and comforting viewers year after year.