Craig Conover and Paige DeSorbo’s Relationship in Southern Charm Season 10: A Look Back

A Love That Felt Unshakeable On Screen

Craig Conover and Paige DeSorbo were the epitome of a happy couple when Southern Charm season 10 was filmed. Their relationship seemed rock-solid, and their interactions on screen were filled with love, mutual respect, and a shared vision for the future. However, knowing that they’ve since broken up after three years together, watching their on-screen dynamic now feels bittersweet. Craig’s life motto during the season, “My whole life is business now. That’s the fun stuff for me now. Making money, getting healthy and f—ing my girlfriend,” takes on a different tone in hindsight. The couple’s plans for marriage, parenthood, and building a life together were central to their storyline, but these moments now hit differently, serving as a reminder of what could have been.

Building a Life Together: A Home for Two

One of the most heartwarming aspects of Craig and Paige’s relationship was their shared vision of building a life together. Craig’s newly finished Charleston home played a significant role in their storyline, symbolizing their commitment to each other. “For Paige and I, time spent in the backyard, that’s our quality time,” Craig revealed in episode 3. He even described the home as a “sanctuary” where they could escape the world and connect. The couple’s shift from a party-heavy lifestyle to a more relaxed, home-centered one seemed like a natural progression of their relationship. However, knowing that they’re no longer together makes these moments feel almost like a preview of a future that never came to fruition.

Freezing the Future: Craig’s Sperm and Parenthood Plans

Craig’s decision to freeze his sperm was a major plot point in season 10, and it’s hard not to cringe at how it plays out now. During episode 4, Craig revealed to friends Austen Kroll and Shep Rose that he and Paige had decided to take this step. While the conversation with his friends was shocking enough, his discussion with Paige was even more surprising. A visibly stunned Paige responded to the idea by saying, “That’s like the craziest thing in the world.” Craig eventually went through with the process, explaining that it was Paige’s decision to hold off on having kids. What’s even more poignant is Craig’s admission that he would have had a different timeline for parenthood if not for Paige. “You date a little while, then you get married, then you have kids,” he said, highlighting how his vision of life had shifted after meeting her.

Sew What? Paige’s Support for Craig’s Passions

Paige was undeniably supportive of Craig’s Sewing Down South company, and their playful banter about his crafting hobby added a lighthearted touch to their relationship. In episode 4, the two even joked about turning one of the rooms in Craig’s house into a multifunctional crafting space. While Paige was on board with a sewing nook, she shut down one of Craig’s more outrageous ideas—a wrapping paper wall—with a definitive, “What the f—? No.” Their dynamic here was affectionate and hilarious, showcasing the fun side of their relationship. However, it’s hard not to wonder how these inside jokes and shared moments factor into their breakup.

Babies in the Bank and the Future They Planned

In episode 5, Craig jokes about hosting a party to celebrate freezing his sperm, but the conversation takes a more serious turn when he reveals that he wants to leave his sperm to Paige if he dies, so she can still have his children. Paige, though initially laughing it off, makes it clear she would never go through with such a plan. “What, I’m going to have a child and then actively not give them a dad?” she asks, emphasizing her belief that children deserve two parents. Craig’s dream of a future with Paige is očividně heartfelt, but their breakup makes it hard not to see this as a missed opportunity.

The White Picket Fence and the Life They Wanted

Craig’s desire for a traditional life with Paige was a recurring theme throughout the season. In episode 7, Shep Rose praises Craig for achieving the “white picket fence existence” he’s always wanted. However, Craig admits that Paige’s indecisiveness about their future together was a source of confusion. “One day she’ll text me and say, ‘Let’s build a f—ing farmhouse in the middle of nowhere.’ Or like, ‘I’m moving to Charleston.’ Then she’ll have a good day in New York and be like, ‘I love it up here,’” he explains. Despite the challenges, Craig seems willing to compromise, acknowledging that life is full of tough decisions. But in the end, it seems like their visions for the future couldn’t align.

To Be or Not to Be: The Fantasy of a Farmhouse and Family

In episode 9, Craig and Paige go on a romantic outing to purchase bees for his Charleston home, a moment that feels almost like a fantasy. Craig confesses that he sometimes imagines a future where they live on a farm with children, but Paige reveals she’s more grounded in reality. “I definitely feel a little pressure. I’m only 31,” she says, addressing the tension around their differing timelines for starting a family. Paige makes it clear that she won’t be rushed into parenthood, declaring, “F— yeah it’s my decision because I’m the one that holds it in my f—ing body.” Craig understands her perspective but can’t help feeling hopeful when Paige talks about their future together. Their breakup makes these conversations feel like a harbinger of what was to come.

Picking Rings, Not Cities: The Engagement That Never Happened

Despite their disagreements, Craig seemed confident that an engagement was on the horizon. In episode 9, he tells Patricia Altschul that he plans to propose by the end of the year and even shows Paige a selection of rings, from which she picks an emerald cut. However, their future together remains uncertain, and Craig admits that they’re not sure where they’ll settle down. “What rule says we have to pick one city?” he asks, highlighting their unconventional approach to life. But in the end, it wasn’t enough to keep them together.

Living in Paige’s World: The Challenges of Compromise

Craig acknowledges that Paige’s career is her top priority and admits that he’s had to learn how to navigate her busy world. “You shouldn’t have to force someone into liking you. If the person likes you, they’ll make time for you,” he says in episode 11, reflecting on the challenges of their relationship. While he admits to feeling insecure about Paige’s schedule, he seems committed to making it work. However, it’s clear that their differences ultimately proved insurmountable.

Southern Charm season 10 serves as a bittersweet reminder of what Craig and Paige once had. Their breakup after filming makes it hard not to revisit their on-screen moments with a sense of nostalgia and regret. What once felt like a love story for the ages now feels like a “what if?” that will never be fully answered.