The Return of Dr. Trey MacDougal: Will Fans See Him Again in And Just Like That?

The world of Sex and the City and its reboot, And Just Like That (AJLT), continues to captivate fans with its intricate relationships, dramatic plot twists, and the possibility of revisiting beloved characters. One such character whose return has sparked excitement is Dr. Trey MacDougal, played by the versatile actor Kyle MacLachlan. In recent days, both MacLachlan and his former co-star Kristin Davis have weighed in on the possibility of Trey making an appearance in the AJLT universe. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what they had to say and what it could mean for the show’s future.

Kyle MacLachlan’s Interest in Returning as Dr. Trey MacDougal

In a recent interview with People on Monday, March 10, Kyle MacLachlan expressed his openness to reprising his role as Dr. Trey MacDougal. The actor’s comments came just days after Kristin Davis, who plays Charlotte York-Goldenblatt, revealed that Trey was at the center of a discarded plotline in the reboot series. Davis had shared on her “Are You a Charlotte?” podcast that a proposed storyline involving Charlotte running into her first husband, Trey, was ultimately rejected. She referred to Trey as Charlotte’s “best match,” a sentiment that resonated with fans of the original series.

MacLachlan responded warmly to Davis’s comments, saying, “That’s so sweet of her. I thought I was her perfect match and then they brought in somebody else. It was sad.” His words hint at a sense of loss and unfinished business, not just for Trey and Charlotte, but also for the fans who invested in their relationship. The actor also revealed that the show’s creators had reached out to him about returning to the role, but he felt the idea needed more depth. “I think it would be really fun to return, yeah, I do,” MacLachlan said. “They had reached out. I just felt that the idea that they had—I wanted a little bit more to it. I wanted the relationship that we had to be a little deeper.”

MacLachlan’s candid admission shows that he is not only willing to return but also eager to explore Trey and Charlotte’s relationship on a more profound level. He left the door open for future discussions, adding, “Maybe they’ll come back with another idea. I’d be game.” This openness from the actor has fans hoping that Trey’s return might still be on the horizon, albeit with a more satisfying and meaningful storyline.

Kristin Davis’s Perspective: A Desire for Closure

Kristin Davis, who has been a close friend of MacLachlan’s, further illuminated the situation during her podcast episode. She confirmed that MacLachlan had indeed declined an offer to appear in AJLT, not because he wasn’t interested, but because he wanted to avoid introducing a “sad note” to Trey’s character arc. “I think he just didn’t want there to be kind of a sad note to the end,” Davis explained. “So, I get that.”

However, Davis also expressed her own desire for fans to find some closure regarding Trey and Charlotte’s relationship. The two characters had a complex and often tumultuous marriage in the original Sex and the City series. After tying the knot in season three, they divorced in season five, with Charlotte eventually moving on to marry Harry Goldenblatt, played by Evan Handler. Despite the divorce, the relationship between Trey and Charlotte left a lasting impact on fans, and many viewers still wonder what could have been.

Davis revealed that Charlotte still harbors an “unfinished feeling” about Trey and that she, as both the character and the actress, would love to see him return in some capacity. “I, Kristin, also feel that way,” she said. She even suggested a potential scenario for Trey’s return, imagining that the two could run into each other at an event or a restaurant. “I think it would be so amazing to have Kyle back on,” she added, expressing her enthusiasm for the idea. Davis also mentioned that she had recently given MacLachlan “a hard time” about his decision, but after hearing his perspective, she understood his reasoning.

This exchange highlights the strong bond between the actors and their investment in the characters they portray. It also underscores the emotional depth of Trey and Charlotte’s relationship and the lasting connection fans feel with their story.

Trey and Charlotte’s Relationship: A Look Back

For those who may need a refresher, Trey MacDougal was introduced in Sex and the City as Charlotte’s first husband. Their relationship was marked by romance, challenges, and eventually, heartbreak. Trey’s struggles with impotence and his family’s disapproval of Charlotte created significant obstacles in their marriage. Despite their efforts to make it work, the couple ultimately decided to go their separate ways.

However, their time together left an indelible mark on Charlotte’s journey. Trey represented a certain ideal of love and partnership that Charlotte had always envisioned for herself. Even after her marriage to Harry, a kind and loyal partner, Charlotte couldn’t help but look back on her time with Trey with a mix of nostalgia and regret. This unfinished business between the two characters has lingered in the minds of fans, making the possibility of their reunion all the more compelling.

The dynamic between Trey and Charlotte also speaks to the broader themes of Sex and the City and And Just Like That. Both series explore the complexities of love, relationships, and personal growth, often leaving audiences with more questions than answers. The potential return of Trey MacDougal serves as a reminder that some relationships, no matter how they end, continue to hold a special place in our hearts.

Why Trey’s Return Could Be Significant

The possibility of Trey MacDougal’s return to And Just Like That is significant for several reasons. First and foremost, it would allow fans to gain closure on a relationship that has always felt somewhat unresolved. While Charlotte has moved on and found happiness with Harry, her connection with Trey remains a pivotal part of her story. A reunion, even if brief, could provide the resolution that both the character and the audience have been seeking.

Secondly, Trey’s return could add depth to the current narrative of And Just Like That. The reboot has already tackled a range of issues, from grief and aging to identity and evolving friendships. By revisiting Trey and Charlotte’s relationship, the show could explore themes of reconnection, forgiveness, and the enduring power of love. It could also serve as a reminder that relationships don’t always end neatly and that the people who once mattered to us can continue to shape who we are.

Finally, Trey’s return would be a nod to the original Sex and the City series, which laid the foundation for the world of And Just Like That. By embracing its roots, the show could foster a sense of continuity and reassure fans that the characters they love are still being thoughtfully developed.

The Possibility of Future Episodes

Despite the initial rejection of the proposed storyline, there is still hope for Trey’s return. Both MacLachlan and Davis have expressed their interest in exploring this possibility further, and it seems that the door is still open for the show’s creators to revisit the idea. As MacLachlan noted, “Maybe they’ll come back with another idea. I’d be game.”

In the meantime, fans continue to hold out hope that Trey will make an appearance in future episodes of And Just Like That. The interest from both the actors and the audience suggests that there is still a story to be told about Trey and Charlotte. Whether it’s a chance encounter, a deeper exploration of their past, or even a new chapter in their relationship, the possibilities are endless.

As the series moves forward, it will be important to strike a balance between honoring the history of Sex and the City and continuing to evolve the characters in meaningful ways. If done right, Trey’s return could be a memorable and impactful moment for the show, one that resonates with both long-time fans and newer viewers.

The Fans’ Perspective: A Desire for Reconnection

The excitement surrounding Trey’s potential return highlights just how invested fans are in the world of And Just Like That. For many viewers, the characters of Sex and the City have become like old friends, and their stories continue to evoke strong emotions and reactions. The possibility of reuniting with a character like Trey MacDougal taps into this deep connection, offering fans a chance to reconnect with a part of the show’s history that has always held a special place in their hearts.

Moreover, the interest in Trey’s return speaks to the broader cultural impact of Sex and the City and its reboot. The show’s exploration of love, relationships, and personal growth continues to resonate with audiences, and the potential for closure in Trey and Charlotte’s story is just one example of how the series can continue to engage and move its viewers.

In the end, the return of Dr. Trey MacDougal is more than just a plot twist—it’s an opportunity for fans to revisit a meaningful part of the Sex and the City universe and to experience the emotional depth that has always set this series apart. While nothing is certain just yet, the enthusiasm from both the cast and the audience ensures that the conversation about Trey’s return will continue to be an exciting topic of discussion.