Why case of jailed Briton Jimmy Lai is major sticking point for Keir Starmer’s relations with China

The UK Government Faces Pressure to Intervene in Jimmy Lai’s Case Amid Talks with China

The UK government is under growing pressure to demand the release of jailed pro-democracy campaigner Jimmy Lai as it seeks to strengthen trade relations with China. Mr. Lai, a prominent media tycoon, is currently on trial in Hong Kong under the city’s national security law, which was introduced by Beijing in 2020 following massive pro-democracy protests. His imprisonment and trial have become a significant point of contention in UK-China relations, with calls mounting for the British government to prioritize his release.

Mr. Lai’s case has gained international attention due to his long-standing advocacy for democracy and freedom of speech in Hong Kong. His arrest and trial have been widely condemned by human rights groups and Western governments, who view the charges against him as politically motivated. As the UK seeks to deepen its economic ties with China, the Lai case has emerged as a moral and political dilemma, forcing the government to balance its strategic interests with its commitment to human rights.

Who is Jimmy Lai, and Why is His Case a British Issue?

Jimmy Lai, a 77-year-old media mogul, has lived in Hong Kong since he was 12, when he arrived as a stowaway on a fishing boat from mainland China. He worked as a child laborer in a garment factory before building a fashion empire, Giordano. After the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre, Lai became a vocal advocate for democracy and later founded the Apple Daily newspaper, a platform that championed free speech in Hong Kong.

In 1994, Mr. Lai became a British citizen, and he has never held a Chinese or Hong Kong passport. However, because he was born in mainland China, Hong Kong authorities consider him a Chinese citizen. Despite his British citizenship, Mr. Lai has been denied consular access and has faced severe restrictions during his imprisonment. His British nationality has made his case a focal point for UK politicians and human rights activists, who argue that the UK has a moral obligation to protect its citizens and uphold democratic values.

Why is Jimmy Lai in Jail?

Mr. Lai’s troubles with the law began during the 2019 pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong, when his Apple Daily newspaper openly supported the protesters and criticized the government. In June 2021, the newspaper was raided by police, its assets were frozen, and its executives were arrested, leading to its closure. Mr. Lai was charged under the national security law with "collusion with foreign forces" and sedition under colonial-era laws. He was also accused of unauthorized assembly for attending protests and fraud for a lease violation, charges he has denied.

The US government has described the fraud charges as "spurious," and human rights groups have condemned the legal proceedings as a blatant attempt to silence dissent. Since his arrest in December 2020, Mr. Lai has been held in a high-security prison, often in solitary confinement. His trial, which began in December 2023, has been marred by delays and restrictions, with the court refusing to dismiss the charges despite international condemnation.

The British Government’s Response to Jimmy Lai’s Imprisonment

The UK government has faced criticism for its inconsistent approach to Mr. Lai’s case. In 2020, then-Prime Minister Boris Johnson expressed "deep concern" over Mr. Lai’s charges, prompting a rebuke from the Chinese embassy in London, which accused the UK of interfering in China’s internal affairs. However, the government’s efforts seemed to wane in the following years, leading campaigners to accuse the UK of prioritizing economic ties with China over human rights.

In recent months, however, there has been a renewed push for action. In May 2023, then-Foreign Secretary James Cleverly raised Mr. Lai’s case directly with Chinese Vice President Han Zheng and criticized Hong Kong for targeting pro-democracy figures. Lord Cameron, who later took over as foreign secretary, called for Mr. Lai’s immediate release, describing his trial as "politically motivated." Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has also vowed to prioritize Mr. Lai’s case in discussions with Beijing, though he has avoided confirming whether he has personally raised the issue with Chinese leaders.

Ongoing Efforts and the Moral Imperative

The pressure on the UK government to act has intensified in recent months, particularly as Mr. Lai’s trial continues. In October, Foreign Secretary David Lammy was urged by UK lawmakers sanctioned by Beijing to raise the case of political prisoners in Hong Kong, including Mr. Lai, during his visit to China. The Foreign Office confirmed that Mr. Lammy pressed Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi on Mr. Lai’s detention, emphasizing the UK’s concerns over human rights in Hong Kong.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves also raised Mr. Lai’s imprisonment during her meetings with Chinese ministers, signaling the UK’s willingness to address contentious issues alongside its efforts to revive economic ties with China. Meanwhile, Mr. Lai’s family and supporters continue to advocate for his release, with his son Sebastien calling on the UK government to "put words into action" and secure his father’s freedom.

The Broader Implications of Jimmy Lai’s Case

Jimmy Lai’s case is not just about one man’s fate; it has far-reaching implications for the future of freedom of speech in Hong Kong and the UK’s role in upholding democratic values globally. As Hong Kong’s national security law continues to be used to silence dissent, Mr. Lai’s trial serves as a stark reminder of the erosion of rights in the city since its handover to China in 1997.

The UK’s response to Mr. Lai’s case will be closely watched as a test of its commitment to human rights in the face of geopolitical and economic pressures. While the government has made some efforts to raise Mr. Lai’s case with Beijing, critics argue that more robust action is needed to secure his release and challenge China’s increasingly authoritarian policies in Hong Kong. As the trial continues, the international community remains hopeful that diplomacy and moral leadership can lead to a just outcome for Jimmy Lai and others like him.