Homeless people kicked out of Brisbane’s parks, tents removed

Brisbane’s Crackdown on Homelessness: A Growing Debate

Brisbane has joined a growing list of cities taking a firmer stance on homelessness, with a recent crackdown on camping in public spaces. The move follows a decision by the City of Moreton Bay Council to outlaw camping on public land, imposing fines of up to $8,065 for those who violate the rule. Brisbane Lord Mayor Adrian Schrinner has expressed support for Moreton Bay Mayor Peter Flannery’s policy, which came into effect on March 12. However, concerns have been raised that this decision could push homeless individuals into Brisbane, exacerbating the city’s existing homelessness crisis.

The Council’s Decision and Its Implications

While Schrinner has backed the Moreton Bay Council’s move, critics argue that the approach may disproportionately harm vulnerable populations. The Brisbane City Council’s Labor opposition has urged Schrinner to reconsider his decision to remove homeless people from Brisbane’s parks within 24 hours. Deputy leader Councillor Lucy Collier has criticized the plan as “heartless,” highlighting the lack of alternative solutions for those forced to live on the streets. Micah Projects CEO Karyn Walsh acknowledges the council’s response as reasonable, noting that parks are not suitable for long-term living. However, she warns that the situation underscores the broader housing crisis, as many homeless individuals remain on waiting lists for affordable housing.

Critics voice concerns about the Crackdown

Opposition to the crackdown has grown, with critics arguing that the policy fails to address the root causes of homelessness. Former Greens lord mayoral candidate Jonathan Sriranganathan has pointed out that claims about homeless individuals “refusing housing” often overlook the reality of the situation. Many are offered placements in unsafe or unhealthy environments, such as overcrowded boarding houses plagued by theft, drug use, and violence. These facilities often separate couples by gender and provide little stability, with evictions possible on short notice. Sriranganathan insists that such conditions are not a viable solution and that refusing them is a rational decision for many.

The Challenges of Temporary Housing

The debate highlights the difficulties faced by those experiencing homelessness, many of whom Reject temporary accommodations like boarding houses in favor of long-term rental options. However, Brisbane’s housing market remains highly competitive, with low vacancy rates and soaring costs, making it nearly impossible for many to secure stable housing. This has left a significant portion of the homeless population with few options but to camp in public spaces. While the council’s policy aims to restore order in public areas, critics argue that it does little to address the systemic issues driving homelessness.

Regional Councils Weigh In

When asked about the potential flow-on effects of Moreton Bay’s crackdown, other south-east Queensland councils expressed varied responses. A Brisbane City Council spokeswoman stated that the issue was a matter for Moreton Bay and emphasized the council’s ongoing collaboration with an inter-agency working group, including police, the Housing Department, and Queensland Health. Redland City Council indicated no plans to change its compassionate approach, which balances the needs of all community members. Logan City Council noted that homeless individuals often prefer to stay near existing support services, making it unlikely for them to relocate to other regions. The Sunshine Coast Council, meanwhile, emphasized its partnership with state government services, providing information and direction to those camping illegally while reserving enforcement as a last resort.

Finding a Way Forward

As the debate continues, the need for a more comprehensive and compassionate approach to homelessness has become clear. Rather than simply enforcing bans on camping, advocates argue for increased investment in affordable housing, improved support services, and policies that address the root causes of homelessness. Without such measures, the cycle of displacement and vulnerability is likely to persist, leaving many without a safe or stable place to call home. The situation in Brisbane serves as a reminder of the urgent need for collaboration between local governments, housing providers, and social services to create meaningful solutions for those in need.