Chuck Schumer links rise in left-wing antisemitism to 2008 crisis, wokeism of ‘radical fringe’ in new book

The Rise of Antisemitism on the American Left: A Growing Concern

Introduction: Understanding the Roots of the Problem

In his newly released book, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer sheds light on a troubling trend: the rise of antisemitism within the American left. Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in U.S. history, attributes this growth to a toxic mix of the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis and radical reinterpretations of history. He describes this development as "extremely painful," especially given the historical alliance between the Jewish community and the left. Schumer argues that while the left was once a "natural home" for many Jews, it is no longer immune to antisemitic ideologies.

The 2008 Financial Crisis and Its Impact on Antisemitism

Schumer traces the resurgence of antisemitism on the left to the 2008 financial crisis. The crisis deepened distrust of financial institutions among many on the left, who began to view bankers and financiers with suspicion. While these sentiments are not inherently antisemitic, Schumer points out that they intersect with long-standing stereotypes about Jews and finance. For instance, conspiracy theories emerged alleging that investment banks like Lehman Brothers transferred billions to Israeli banks before collapsing. These theories, though baseless, tapped into historical prejudices, illustrating how economic downturns can reignite old biases.

Historical Roots of Left-Wing Antipathy Toward Israel

Schumer also identifies deeper historical roots of left-wing antipathy toward Israel, tracing it back to his time as a student at Harvard over fifty years ago. He notes that this sentiment was closely tied to perceptions of race and oppression. An intellectual framework emerged on the left that cast Israel as an oppressor in a global struggle between the oppressed and the oppressor. Schumer laments that the Jewish community’s history of persecution is increasingly dismissed by radical fringe groups, who view Jews as having overcome prejudice and now being among the powerful. This narrative has led some young Jews to feel guilty and responsible for perceived injustices.

The Challenge of Addressing Antisemitism on the Left

Schumer admits that combating antisemitism on the left is more challenging than addressing it on the right. While right-wing antisemitism is often overt and expected, the left’s version can be more insidious and unintentional. Schumer acknowledges that some left-aligned figures have crossed lines by using antisemitic tropes while criticizing Israel. He specifically mentions Rep. Ilhan Omar’s 2019 tweet about U.S. support for Israel being "all about the Benjamins," though he notes her subsequent apology. Schumer emphasizes that such incidents mark a disturbing shift, as Jewish Americans are now hearing harmful stereotypes from former allies on the left.

The Far-Left and Anti-Israel Sentiment

The current far-left uproar over Israeli military actions in Gaza further illustrates the issue. While many protesters are motivated by a desire to support Palestinians, certain slogans and chants have crossed into antisemitic territory. Schumer singles out the chant "From the river to the sea/Palestine will be free" as a dog whistle that echoes historic calls for the eradication of Jews. He argues that such language should be condemned, just as society has moved away from other offensive phrases with problematic origins.

A Call to Action: Combating Antisemitism on the Left

In conclusion, Schumer urges the left to remain vigilant against antisemitism within its ranks. He warns against complacency and the temptation to overlook bigotry in pursuit of justice. Schumer emphasizes the importance of not letting passion override moral instincts, cautioning that even well-intentioned movements can perpetuate injustice if they tolerate antisemitism. His book serves as a warning and a call to action, urging the left to reflect on its values and ensure that the fight against oppression does not inadvertently perpetuate hatred.